Naniwa Ereji - Film (Movie) Plot and Review

(Osaka Elegy)

Japan, 1936

Director: Kenji Mizoguchi

Production: Daiichi Eiga; black and white, 35mm. Released 1936.

Screenplay: Yoshikata Yoda, from the story "Mieko" by Saburo Okada; photography: Minoru Miki; sound: Hisashi Kase and Yasumi Mizoguchi.

Cast: Isuzu Yamada ( Ayako Murai ); Benkei Shinganoya ( Sonosuke ); Eitaro Shindo ( Yoshizo Fujino ); Kensaku Hara ( Susumu Nishimura ); Seiichi Takegawa ( Ayako's father ); Shinpachiro Asaka ( Ayako's brother ); Chiyoko Okura ( Ayako's sister ); Yoko Umemura ( Sonosuke's wife ); Shizuko Takezawa ( Mine Fukuda ); Kuneo Tamura ( Doctor Yoko ); Kiyoko Okubo ( Doctor's wife ).



Anderson, Joseph, and Donald Richie, The Japanese Film: Art and Industry , New York, 1960; revised edition, Princeton, 1982.

Ve-Ho, Kenji Mizoguchi , Paris, 1963.

Mesnil, Michel, Kenji Mizoguchi , Paris, 1965.

Yoda, Yoshikata, Mizoguchi Kenji no hito to geijutsu [Kenji Mizoguchi: The Man and His Art], Tokyo, 1970.

Tessier, Max, Kenji Mizoguchi , Paris, 1971.

Mellen, Joan, Voices from the Japanese Cinema , New York, 1975.

Mellen, Joan, The Waves at Genji's Door: Japan Through Its Cinema , New York, 1976.

Bock, Audie, Japanese Film Directors , New York, 1978; revised edition, Tokyo, 1985.

Burch, Noël, To the Distant Observer: Form and Meaning in the Japanese Cinema , Berkeley, 1979.

Freiberg, Freda, Women in Mizoguchi Films , Melbourne, 1981.

Sato, Tadao, Currents in Japanese Cinema , Tokyo, 1982.

Andrew, Dudley, Kenji Mizoguchi: A Guide to References and Resources , Boston, 1982.

Serceau, Daniel, Mizoguchi: De la révolte aux songes , Paris, 1983.

Andrew, Dudley, Film in the Aura of Art , Princeton, 1984.

McDonald, Keiko, Mizoguchi , Boston, 1984.

Kirihara, Donald, Patterns of Time: Mizoguchi and the 1930s , Madison, 1992.

O'Grady, Gerald, editor, Mizoguchi the Master , Ontario, 1996.

Tomasi, Dario, Kenji Mizoguchi , Milan, 1998.


"Mizoguchi Issue" of Cinéma (Paris), no. 6, 1955.

Richie, Donald, and Joseph Anderson, "Kenji Mizoguchi," in Sight and Sound (London), Autumn 1955.

"Mizoguchi Issue" of Ecran (Paris), February-March 1958.

"Mizoguchi Issue" of Cahiers du Cinéma (Paris), March 1958.

Iwasaki, Akira, "Mizoguchi," in Anthologie du cinema 29 , Paris, 1967.

Yoda, Yoshikata, "The Density of Mizoguchi's Scripts," in Cinema (Los Angeles), Spring 1971.

Braucourt, G., and others, "Trois cinéastes de la femme," in Ecran (Paris), August-September 1974.

Cros, J. L., in Image et Son (Paris), April 1978.

Sato, Tadao, and Dudley Andrew, "On Kenji Mizoguchi," in Film Criticism (Edinboro, Pennsylvania), Spring 1980.

McDonald, K., "Form and Function in Osaka Elegy ," in Film Criticism (Edinboro, Pennsylvania), Winter 1982.

Russell, Catherine, "'Overcoming Modernity': Gender and the Pathos of History in Japanese Film Melodrama," in Camera Obscura (Bloomington), no. 35, May 1995.

Burdeau, Emmanuel, and others, "Mizoguchi Encore," in Cahiers du Cinéma (Paris), no. 504, July-August 1996.

Hoberman, J., "Great Leaps Backward," in The Village Voice (New York), vol. 41, no. 38, 17 September 1996.

* * *

The term "feminist" has been applied to the films of Kenji Mizoguchi frequently and somewhat indiscriminately. The term can involve three rather different approaches: 1) films that explicitly confront and endorse the theories and values of the women's liberation movement; 2) films that analyze the ways in which women are oppressed within society; and 3) films in which the director appears to identify with, show special sympathy for, female characters. The interest in Mizoguchi's work is that it covers this entire spectrum of approaches. Only two of his films that have become accessible in the West ( Victory of Women and My Love Has Been Burning ) employ the first approach (both belong to the immediate aftermath of World War II and to the enforced "democratization" of Japan under the American occupation). The late films, especially, are examples of the third approach, and involve the constant risk of succumbing to traditional male-created myths of women, especially woman-as-redeemer, with the emphasis on female sacrifice. Osaka Elegy (as it is generally known in the West), like Sisters of Gion made later in the same year, is that of the second approach. Here the risk is that the films will become "melodramas of defeat," reinforcing myths of woman-as-victim, with an emphasis on female masochism.

The importance of Osaka Elegy lies in its position within the series of increasingly radical feminist films that culminates in the magnificent My Love Has Been Burning (1949), one of Mizoguchi's greatest achievements, for which no equivalent exists within the commercial cinema of the West. Osaka Elegy marks, in many respects, a point of hesitation prior to the director's total (if temporary) commitment to feminist principles. Noël Burch is clearly correct (in To the Distant Observer ) in arguing for the superiority of Sisters of Gion , though it is a pity the argument is conducted on purely formal grounds: the formal and stylistic rigour of the later film is paralleled in its altogether tougher and more uncompromising treatment of women's oppression, central to which is its female protagonist, whom the film credits with a rebelliousness and ideological awareness far beyond that of Ayako in Osaka Elegy (the two characters are played, splendidly, by

Naniwa ereji
Naniwa ereji
the same actress, Isuzu Yamada, which underlines the continuity between the two films).

As Noël Burch suggests, Osaka Elegy is stylistically torn between a capitulation to the codes of dominant cinema—Hollywood—and the repudiation of them marked so emphatically by Sisters of Gion . It is also torn, thematically and dramatically, between the female masochism of earlier Mizoguchi films (such as Taki No Shiraito , 1933) and the feminist protest to come—marvellously anticipated in the final shot, in which Ayako walks and stares straight into camera, with a look combining defiance with denunciation of the society (i.e., the film's contemporary audience) that has condemned her to prostitution. The film also has a dimension lacking in its successors: an analysis of the oppression of women within the family, in the name of familial "loyalty" and "duty"—the duty of the daughter to serve, unquestioningly, father and brother.

Where Sisters of Gion breaks with the codes of western cinema, Osaka Elegy evokes direct comparison with certain Hollywood films of the same period, especially the films of von Sternberg with Marlene Dietrich, where the resemblance is stylistic as well as thematic. It lacks the extraordinary excess and obsessiveness that give the von Sternberg films their unique distinction; on the other hand, the political rigour that was to characterize the Mizoguchi films centred on women up to 1950 is here more than embryonic.

—Robin Wood

User Contributions:

Comment about this article, ask questions, or add new information about this topic: